Good care is about personal responsibility

What is the best way to take the temperature of the NHS? Ask the patient’s relatives. This is why the Cure the NHS organisation has such a powerful voice – or at least it should have,

I try to avoid hysteria and over reporting of bad news stories about the NHS in this blog but every so often I have to share a ‘tale from the front line’

A friend’s husband, a fit and active 70 year old (I’ll call him Tom), recently fell and broke his hip while walking his dog. Two weeks later, he is a frail, broken elderly in-patient with bed sores and a post-operative infection. The care he has received in the hospital in Hampshire has been poor – very poor. Tom’s wife, we’ll call her Liz, is a retired nurse, so she knows something about care and standards. Liz was horrified to note that Tom had bed sores, nasty places on his back and ankle, and challenged one of the nurses about how this could happen. Surely he was being turned regularly – the essential protocol to avoid the breaking down of thin skin due to pressure, lack of movement and poor circulation. ‘Ah’ said the nurse in charge, ‘that would be the agency nurses’. A cheap shot and a poor example of ownership, leadership and responsibility.

Liz also noticed that untouched food was left out of reach from Tom and now makes sure she is there at meal times so she can make sure he eats.To add insult to injury, Liz noticed that the floor beneath Tom’s bed was filthy, with unidentified stains and dust. It was clear that this was of no concern to the nurses when Liz pointed out that this dirt could be an infection risk, so she asked if she could borrow a mop and bucket and clean the floor herself. She was advised that there were no cleaning materials kept on the ward (apart from antiseptic solutions and wipes), as the contract cleaners were in charge of that. Liz enquired whether the contract cleaners could be called to undertake this task and was advised that they only appeared on the ward on pre-arranged times.

Have we learnt nothing from the Mid Staffs scandal? How come if you drop a bottle of tomato ketchup in a supermarket a cleaner appears within minutes? How often have we all heard ‘could a cleaner please go to platform 1’ at our stations but not so in a hospital?

A visit to the NHS choices website gives this particular hospital some reasonable ratings. 8.9/10 for cleanliness, 7.74/10 for overall care and 4.5/5 for patient feedback. Perhaps Tom has been unlucky – maybe an unfortunate set of circumstances has led to this isolated, but nonetheless, unacceptable lapse in service? But this is a very personal crisis and Liz fears that Tom, a normally robust and positive personaility, has given up and may not survive this episode.

Professor Don Berwick, the man tasked in improving patient safety in the NHS, says that redesign of service delivery is needed to make ‘zero harm a reality’. He lists seven imminently sensible criteria to be assessed and improved:

•  Identifying aims for improvement in quality
•  Building capacity through training and education
• Oversight, accountability and influence
• Patient and public involvement
• Measurement, tracking, transparency and learning
• Impact for legal penalties and criminal liability on patient safety
•  Leadership

I absolutely agree with all of the above and will be fascinated to see the outcomes of this initiative. But in the meantime, let’s try to keep this real. Behind the jargon and theory, there are two key players – the care givers and the care receivers. If you ask any patient or their relatives what they want out of the care givers I would guess that their number one request would be simple. Ownership and responsibility. Don't blame agency nurse, contract cleaners, the doctors, targets, budget cuts, reform, phase of the moon or anything else. Ultimately – whoever you are, if you are caring for a patient, it is your responsibility to be the best and do the best you possibly can.

Or am I being naïve?